The short answer: In legal surrogacy agreements, the intended parents are recognized as the baby’s legal and custodial parents—not the surrogate mother. However, laws vary by country and state, so proper contracts are essential.
Here’s a breakdown of legal parenthood, custody rights, and potential risks in surrogacy.
1. Legal Parenthood in Gestational vs. Traditional Surrogacy
A. Gestational Surrogacy (Most Common)
- Surrogate has no genetic ties to the baby (egg comes from a donor or intended mother).
- Intended parents are legal parents from birth (if contracts are properly executed).
- Pre-birth orders (court rulings) confirm parental rights before delivery in surrogacy-friendly states (e.g., California, Illinois).
B. Traditional Surrogacy (Rare & Risky)
- Surrogate is the biological mother (her egg + intended father’s sperm).
- Legal risks: Some states/countries grant her parental rights unless terminated via adoption.
- Not recommended due to custody disputes.
2. How Legal Parenthood Is Established
Before Birth
✔ Surrogacy contract signed by all parties.
✔ Court order (pre-birth or post-birth, depending on state laws).
At Birth
- In surrogacy-friendly states, intended parents are listed on the birth certificate immediately.
- In restrictive states, intended parents may need to adopt the baby post-birth (even if genetically related).
International Surrogacy Risks
- Some countries (France, Germany, Italy) ban surrogacy, making legal parenthood difficult.
- In India, Mexico, or Ukraine, foreign parents may face custody battles if laws change.
3. Can a Surrogate Keep the Baby?
- In gestational surrogacy: Extremely rare—courts almost always favor intended parents if contracts are valid.
- In traditional surrogacy: Higher risk—surrogate could claim parental rights.
Famous Cases:
- Baby M (1986) – Traditional surrogate fought for custody (court eventually granted custody to intended parents).
- International disputes – Some countries have detained babies born via surrogacy until legal battles resolve.
4. How to Protect Parental Rights
✔ Choose gestational surrogacy (avoid traditional surrogacy).
✔ Work with a reputable agency to ensure legal compliance.
✔ Hire a surrogacy lawyer to draft contracts and secure pre-birth orders.
✔ Avoid countries with unstable surrogacy laws (e.g., sudden bans).
5. Key Takeaways
✅ Intended parents own the baby if contracts are properly executed.
✅ Surrogates cannot claim custody in gestational surrogacy (if legal steps are followed).
✅ Laws vary widely—always consult a lawyer before starting surrogacy.
Need legal help? Contact a reproductive attorney in your state/country.
